Friday, June 10, 2011

Let's Talk About Stats, Baby

I just thought I'd write a few quick thoughts about stats as they pertain to healers, and then a little chatter about stats as they pertain to discipline priests specifically. Because aren't disc priests about the most interesting people in the world? They drive fast cars, move in fast crowds, heal with spectacular style before burning out and dying of a cocaine overdose. (RIP BubblesTheCokeMonkey.)


...Anyway


Stats are generally considered to exist along a couple of axes (plural of axis, not axe): mana efficiency and throughput. Mana efficiency helps dictate how long your mana pool will sustain your healing activities and throughput dictates how much healing you can pour into any constrained period of time. Throughput is always crucial in any current content, while mana efficiency's importance varies with how far one is into the expansion.

The reason why mana efficiency's importance varies is fairly straightforward: spell costs are based on one's base mana (the mana pool you have with no gear equipped) while regeneration scales with your stats. The two tend to synch until you reach level cap, because each level raises your base mana and, therefore, your spell costs. Once you reach level cap, however, your advancement is no longer level-based but gear-based. Your base mana is locked in "forever" (that is, until the next expansion raises the level cap) but your stats keep increasing with better gear. This creates an asymmetrical dynamic and, as the expansion wears on, the mana pool and mana regen that your gear provides will begin to trivialize spell costs.

For now, mana efficiency tends to be useful, but already the use is variable. I find that the only normal raid encounter for which mana efficiency can matter is the Nefarian encounter in Blackwing Descent. Mana efficiency does matter to varying degrees in heroic raid encounters. However, next tier, mana efficiency is going to start fading fast as any kind of priority. Bear that in mind as we go through the stats.

Getting back to my original line of thought, I think that looking at mana efficiency and throughput as separate categories is imprecise. Certain stats have an element of each and each component needs to be kept in mind.


Intellect Is OP


On the World of Warcraft stat forums, all the other caster stats write long, angry posts about how intellect is unbalanced and overpowered. They're right, but tough luck. Blizzard has made a clear and conscious design decision that intellect should always be the #1 choice of any caster. Unless they reverse that decision, and it doesn't seem likely that they will*, you will always want intellect first, any time there's a choice. It provides mana efficiency, throughput and candy all at the same time.

*The reason I say that it's unlikely that Blizzard will ever reverse the decision to make intellect far and away the best caster stat is because it's a standard role-playing trope that there be a certain stat that is defining for a class (generally intellect for magic-users, strength for power-based weapon-users and agility for speed-based weapon-users). A game like WoW might try to subvert common tropes early on, to try to find a "new way," but when it decides to finally adhere to one late in its development (WoW is now about 6 years old, which is pretty far into a game's development), it generally means the design team decided it was a convention worth sticking with. The time for experimenting with that particular aspect is probably over.

It provides mana efficiency because your mana pool is directly increased by your intellect. Larger mana pools mean a larger buffer to cast from before you run dry, but if that's all they were, it wouldn't mean much. However, a number of mana regeneration tools operate by providing your a percentage of your total mana pool back periodically. That means, the larger your mana pool, the more mana you're going to get back over time when these mechanics are in play.

The throughput largely comes from the boost intellect gives the output of any damaging or healing spell known as spellpower. You get spellpower at a one-for-one rate from intellect, but each spell has its own modifier for what fraction of your spellpower gets added to the spell's output (known as the spellpower coefficient). This is added to every spell and is a pure throughput boost.

Finally, don't forget that intellect provides candy. And in a wholesome way, not dispensed from a scruffy stranger in a nondescript van. The form of this candy is a little bit of extra spell critical strike. It's not a massive amount, but the previous effects were enough to make intellect fantastic, so this is just gravy. Candy gravy. Mmm, food metaphor stew.


Spirit Swings


Spirit is a little bit like intellect. It's sort of the little sister to intellect's big sister. It tries to emulate intellect, and does a decent job, but falls crucially short. Just like every younger sibling.* You see, like intellect, spirit is both good for mana efficiency and throughput. However, here's the big difference: it can't do both at the same time. Intellect can.

*If you're a younger sibling that was traumatized by just now reading what the world has been telling you your entire life, please send all psychiatric bills to your parents, c/o a cold, cruel world.

So spirit provides mana regeneration in the very straightforward manner of giving you a constant mana-per-five-seconds rate of return. For most healers, the rate is halved in combat (holy priests, bless their mana-burning hearts, get a talent to increase it to 80% of their  out-of-combat rate). For casters who weren't quite able to pass medical school, spirit provides nothing at all in combat. So, this component is easy and direct: more spirit, more mana provided over time during an encounter.

The less-appreciated aspect of spirit is that it can be converted into throughput. In a sense, this is semantics, because this isn't a separate power, but it's still an important observation: having more spirit, and therefore more mana regen, allows you to cast more mana-inefficient spells (but better throughput ones). The reason this is an important point to make is because healers often start reforging away from or otherwise dumping spirit too early. They've just become comfortable with their ability to last throughout encounters, so decide they should move toward more throughput stats. However, since they aren't at the point where mana is largely irrelevant, they suddenly find themselves in a tough encounter (either a new progression fight, or a fight they've done but isn't going well this time) and suddenly mana is leaking away alarmingly fast. If they had stuck with the spirit, though, they would have their comfortable regeneration rate now when they need it. And on fights where they don't need it, they can cast more fast, strong spells to convert the mana regen into throughput (in much the same way Einstein discovered that you can convert matter to energy).

Spirit is a swing stat. On fights where your mana pool is more than sufficient, you can make it do throughput tricks. On fights where you need mana, you can let it do its usual mana regeneration thing. Intellect gives both at the same time, spirit makes you choose.


The Eternal War Between Haste And Crit


Read ten different blogs dedicated to healing and you'll get...uh, well, two different opinions on which is better. I guess there's not a lot of position choices here. However, let me illuminate the parameters of the schism and you can make your own choice as an informed consumer of stats.

Both of these stats are pure throughput stats, in that neither provides a mana efficiency benefit (the way intellect and spirit do). However, that's not the whole story. One of these stats does impact mana efficiency, just not in the positive direction. Of course, even that comes with a little complexity. Almost like little people, these stats are complicated and multifaceted.

Haste does what you'd expect: it makes you a faster caster. This is manifested in three ways, two of which I'll mention now, one in a moment. The most obvious effect is reducing the cast times on spells that aren't instant. The less obvious but also important effect is to reduce the GCD (global cooldown) that limits how quickly you can do most abilities in succession. Reducing the GCD is important in pumping out instant-cast spells faster.

This obviously has the effect of raising throughput. Your heals per second are going to go up if the seconds consumed by casting go down for the same effect. However, it also has the effect of reducing your mana efficiency. To realize the throughput benefits of haste, you must cast more spells in the same amount of time and each spell still costs what it did before. Net result: your burn through your mana faster in order to raise your throughput.

However. There is an exception to this, and it's due to the third effect of haste. The third effect of haste is that it speeds up the ticking of your HoT (healing over time) spells. HoTs provide a certain amount of healing every "tick" over a fixed duration. The more haste you have, the more healing ticks you get in that duration. Therefore more haste means more throughput from each HoT, notionally. In practice, this is one of the most complicated things to math out, because you need to add a certain amount of haste for the HoT to speed up enough to get one more tick in before the duration ends (known as a "haste breakpoint")...and every HoT has different haste breakpoints. Still, there are online tools and tables that can help you figure out how much haste you need to reach the next breakpoint for any particular spell. The crucial thing to understand here is that this is an application of haste that increases throughput with no ill effects on mana efficiency. Your HoTs will still cost the same and run for as long before they need to be refreshed. They'll just heal for more (if you reach the breakpoints).

So let's now examine critical strike. Critical strike raises your chance of a healing spell cast to be a "critical heal," which means that its effect is multiplied. Right now, it's multiplied by 1.5x. With the coming patch 4.2, a critical heal will be multiplied by 2x. Critical strike does not share haste's downside. You don't have to spend any extra mana to realize the throughput benefits...some of your spells will simply heal for more, no muss, no fuss.

Critical strike, however, has its own dark side: it's random. It's the stuff of chaos, it swirled in the primordial universe before the gods brought order. This presents a problem if you like predictable throughput. You cannot count on critical strike throughput when you need a large heal, because most likely you will not get one on any specific cast. Further, you may get one when you're topping someone off and lose the benefits of it to overheal. This does de-value it to some extent, because you cannot account for it and tailor your heals appropriately to ensure none of it is wasted. You have to heal as though it's not there and let it pop up and surprise you here and there and hope that over the course of the fight, not much of it is wasted.

The added complexity that critical strike brings with it is that there are a number of talents that are activated by a critical strike heal. These talents boost the value of critical strike. They don't make critical strike any less random (nor should they, randomness is its nature!) but they do increase the rewards when you pop a critical.

So which is better? Well, from a philosophical standpoint, if you value more predictable throughput that you can plan for heal by heal, haste is better. If you value increasing your throughput without harming your mana efficiency, critical strike is for you. However, when you factor in the complexities of haste breakpoints for HoTs and talents that activate off critical strike, the question becomes a lot more difficult and is also quite class- and spec-dependent. It's a war that will rage in the cosmos for thousands of years.


Mastery: "I'm Here Too, Guys..."


The thing to understand about mastery is that it (quite intentionally, I assume) marries the benefits of critical strike and haste, thereby carrying the downsides of neither. Like haste, it is predictable...it carries none of the randomness of critical strike. Like critical strike, it provides its throughput with no ill effects on your mana efficiency...it does not force you to expend more mana to utilize it, like haste does. This description of mastery is true for every healing class.

That is not to say that it is equally valuable for every healing class. Mastery sounds a bit like spellpower in terms of it having all the positives of throughput and none of the drawbacks, but there's a crucial difference. Spellpower passively powers up every heal you cast. Mastery only powers up spells based on certain conditions, and those conditions vary by class and spec. That can drastically effect its value, so there's not a lot more to say about mastery that can apply generically.


Stats Get Hotter When Disciplined


So obviously I think discipline priests are about the sexiest and best-designed healers ever to grace God's green MMO. However, I'm a little biased: I love beautiful things.

All that said,  here's a little objective evidence: every one of these stats is awesome for discipline priests. Sure, we may in certain situations want a bit more of this or that...but we don't hate any of the stats and they're all pretty great. The only itemization concerns we ever have is a general striving for balance, because we want everything. You'll rarely hear a discipline priest say "Yeah, I could really use that except it has critical strike" or "My tier pieces are terribly itemized for me" (though complaining about tier set bonuses? Gladly!).

So, discipline priests are in a good place. Intellect and spirit are obviously good for us (they're good for everyone, at least in this brief window of time where mana efficiency matters), we have a bunch of talents that activate from critical stike, it's always nice to be able to cast faster at need and our mastery boosts our many glittering shields (and any discipline priest who doesn't love bigger shields is a communist and a fascist at the same time. I don't think that's too harsh).

So, was this final section actually meant to be informative or simply a blatant advertisement for how awesome discipline priests are? Yes. After all, knowing that discipline priests are awesome is valuable information for everyone.

Saturday, June 4, 2011

Go On, Blow Your Mana In An Orgy Of Heals

Pacing yourself is overrated. A common healer mistake, one that I am particularly prone to even now, is that mana must be carefully managed and paced so that it's parceled out evenly through the encounter. After all, you don't want to go out of mana, do you? Especially not in Clutch Time, when it's getting late and the clock is ticking down and the home team (that's your raid) is down by a few points?

The problem is that all damage really is created equal. Well, not precisely and I'll get to how it's not, but it's still a good generalized principle which I'll illustrate with some back-of-the-envelope math (I call it Casual Jerks theorycrafting).


Formulas Are Pro


This is your raid's effective health:

Health Pool(raid) + Mana Pool(healers) * HPM(healers) + Combat MP5 Regen(healers) * HPM(healers)

HPM = heals per mana point
Combat MP5 Regen = every source of mana regeneration combined and placed in a standardized "per 5 seconds" frame of reference 

(Bonus points to those who noticed I didn't reduce the equation to its simplest form. I chose not to just to make each element discrete: the literal health pools plus the healing done from the healers' mana pools plus the healing done from the mana the healers regenerate through the fight.)

There may be some slight alterations one could make to that (troll racial health regen for the win?), but that pretty much sums up all the health that the raid will have available to them for the entire encounter. We can view it as one large health pool that the raid draws from collectively. This is clearly not accurate in every way, as individuals do not share in the collective so losing a certain 180k health from that pool (say all the hit points of a particular tank) has a pretty major effect. But it works for the point I am about to make.

All of that health is what is available to you and, beyond making sure that everyone has at least 1 hp at all times, you just need to ensure that the boss health pool goes to 0 before that raid health pool goes to 0. Even if only 1 hp remains to the raid (maybe to an intrepid healer who dealt the coup de grace before being coup de graced herself), if the boss hit 0, you are the winners.

Your mana pool, as a healer, is one piece of that collective health pool and, with certain major caveats that I will detail in a moment, it doesn't matter when you use that mana pool, just so long as you do use it.


Let Me Repeat That With Pizazz


Let me put that another, more controversial way: it is better by far to go out of mana halfway through the fight (bearing in mind the caveats I am about to mention) than to wipe with any mana left in the tank. The reason for this is simple: your contribution to the raid's health pool is fixed for any single encounter. It is the amount of heals you can cast with your mana pool, factoring in the regen you experience during the fight. This and no more. Paced, not paced...it is virtually fixed (with yet another caveat, which is also coming in just a moment).

This means that whether you use those heals early, middle, late or carefully measured out over all those periods, your contribution is the same. Hypothetically, if you burned through your mana in the first minute of an eight minute fight, that means less healing for your other healers and they now have more mana for the remaining seven minutes.


More Fine Print Than A Predatory Bank Loan


Now before I get comments telling me what an irresponsible piece of advice that is, let me finally get to the caveats which are rather important.

All of the above only holds true as long as you are observing all of the following caveats:

Caveat No. 1: You are not overhealing. Well, duh. Any heal that is an overheal is wasting mana and reduces your fixed contribution to the Raid Effective Health. For shame.

Caveat No. 2: You are not causing other healers to overheal. Heal sniping (that is, rushing to cast an unnecessary quick heal to address damage that another healer has covered) is just as criminal as sniping in real life with guns. And if another healer overheals due to you, it's just as bad as you overhealing.

Caveat No. 3: Your zeal to heal during a certain portion of the fight is not leaving other healers at max mana. If you burn through your mana to such an extent that other healers aren't healing at all, and therefore sitting at mana cap, then they are wasting potential mana regen...which is part of their "fixed contribution" to raid health. Uh oh, that "fixed contribution" is looking less and less fixed. Didn't I have a caveat about that? Yes, it's coming soon.

All three of those conditions must be met for what I said above to be true, that it doesn't matter when you spend your mana and when you go out of mana. The moment any of those three aren't true, you're not doing it right and if you go out of mana, you've hurt your raid.

Fixed Contribution Caveat: Okay, so about that fixed contribution I kept mentioning. It's not really fixed, but I simplified it to make a point that I feel is valid. First of all, my claiming it fixed based on my cute little toy formula was based on ideal play: you are never overhealing and never wasting mana regen and you are exercising every cooldown to increase your mana regen optimally. People don't play perfectly, so that rather "unfixes" your contribution. Further, even if you played optimally, there's that pesky "HPM" variable in said formula. You can and always will adjust this on the fly and depending on how you adjust this (to balance with throughput aka heals per second), your contribution will be variable.

Okay, that was the caveat. The caveat essentially boiling down to "What I said before isn't really true." However, the overarching point is that there's a limited range to which you can change the raid's effective health pool based upon your stats and, whether we call it fixed or not, it doesn't matter when you use your portion of the raid's health pool, as long as the Basic Three Rules (given above) are met.


Okay, So What's Your Point?


So why am I mentioning this, in such a long-winded manner, at all? To say this: when in doubt, use mana. Don't be silly and spam your most mana inefficient spell from the start of combat until you run dry, but don't cancel a heal because you're unsure of whether you'll need that mana later. That damage must be healed...if not by you, then by one of your fellow healers. If you heal it, then a fellow healer doesn't and she will have more mana later which balances you not having that mana later. However, if you don't heal it and someone dies and the situation devolves and you wipe with 40% of your mana...well, my friend, you just paced yourself out of some shiny purple fancies.

It's tempting to try to use mana evenly over the course of the fight so that you run dry the moment the boss wheezes, falls over and says, "If it weren't for you meddlesome kids...!" before expiring. But since fights proceed in a non-linear manner and the exact time is not always the same, it's generally very hard to pace it out precisely.

From my experience (and we can file this in the "my experiences not necessarily typical" category), most wipes are not due to the healers running out of mana (when it comes to raids; heroic five-mans are another story when the healer is only just barely geared enough). Instead, most wipes (other than ones caused by failure to observe the fight mechanics) occur because the throughput at a certain moment was not sufficient between all the healers. No correctly handled raid mechanic leads to more damage than appropriately geared healers are capable of healing through. So, unless the mechanics were not handled correctly or people were not appropriately geared, these wipes are due to simply not healing enough: either not casting a heal when you could have or not casting a sufficiently strong one because you were conserving mana.

So the take-home, as far as I'm concerned is that it's better to err on the side of running out of mana too early rather than too late. It's better to challenge your mana pool than to play it cautiously. You must observe the three caveats laid out above, but as long as you have, heal away.

You may say I'm being a tad extremist about using mana with wild abandon, but there's a reason for that. I believe that healers are, by nature, overly cautious and it leads to less performance than they are capable of. This includes myself. I think it's worth harping on this, that a point of healing late in the encounter is not worth more than a point of healing early in the encounter. As long as your healing is not being wasted or causing another healer to waste resources, all healing is created equal. Therefore, so long as you are using all your mana and all your mana regen capability, it really doesn't matter where you use it.

Caveat About The Entire Post: None of this holds true for those rare encounters where the boss regularly reduces players to a percentage of their health or to a set amount of health. In this tier, that means Chimaeron and his little brother* Baron Ashbury. In those fights, obviously, there's plenty of chance to waste healing and therefore you do need to pace yourself. But that's one of those freak show gimmicks in which the laws of time and space don't hold true and you do what you must to survive.

*May not be lore-accurate

Sunday, May 29, 2011

Character Audits

Lisa: Well, I know. But as the employer, it is your job to make your employees feel that they are part of the decision-making process.
Dave: Is this something you learned from that stupid book on Japanese management techniques?
Lisa: You don't actually have to LISTEN to them. Just pretend to. It helps to create a more harmonious group energy.
Dave: Again, is this from that stupid book on Japanese management techniques?
Lisa: This is just a standard management technique that has been used by personnel supervisors since the days of Ho Lu, grand emperor of the Wu dynasty. 

-Newsradio 


An idea that I have been kicking around is a "guild character audit" system. It's similar in philosophy to co-worker evaluations that some companies experiment with, wherein employees are (generally) randomly assigned a fellow co-worker and they provide evaluations of that person once a year or several times a year or what-have-you. Generally, the person you evaluate is not the one evaluating you (reducing though not eliminating the chances of collusion). It can be a secret as to whom is doing who's evaluation or, on the other end of the spectrum, the person does the evaluation (after some prep time) in a session with the co-worker they are evaluating (and the manager, usually).

I am not here to laud or condemn the practice in the workplace. However, I think this could be a valuable tool within a guild to keep everyone accountable for being up to par for raiding while distributing the work to ensure that everyone is held so accountable.

The idea is not that guild members will critique each other's game play. One could do this, but I am not suggesting it and I think it probably is a poor idea, for reasons which I'll go into briefly at the end. What I am suggesting is that each guild member is randomly assigned another guild member to evaluate the night before, or two nights before, a guild raid. The evaluation will essentially be a character audit...checking that gear is gemmed and enchanted, all glyph slots are being used and that spec-appropriate gear, gems, enchants and glyphs are being used.

Now, let me quickly clarify something. This is not supposed to be a discussion or debate on the best way to gear/gemchant. This is supposed to be a cursory pass to ensure your evaluation target is not doing anything grossly wrong. If your evaluation target is a mage and he/she has stamina gems or a dodge enchant...that should be red flag. If a prime or major glyph slot has been left empty, that should be a red flag. If he/she is a plate-wearing DPS but has equipped an epic with parry on it, red flag. This is purely meant as a way for the "collective" of the guild to be aware of all potential issues that could hamper the guild in a raid. Perhaps the person has a good reason for doing something that most would view as completely wrong. At least it's a known issue and they can explain to the raid leadership what they're doing and the raid leadership can approve it or not.

Of course, the guild master or raid leader or an officer could do all of the character audits. However, that could be extremely time-consuming. Especially when it comes to something like a DPS using a glyph that boosts an ability that his/her spec does not even use in their rotation. Such a mistake is clearly as bad as overlooking an empty gem slot, but it wouldn't be obvious to someone who doesn't know much about that class. This is the second aspect of such a system. If the person you draw to audit is a hunter, for example, you should check what spec(s) he/she is using and get a minimal understanding of how that class-spec works.

Let's be clear: the idea is not that you have to become an expert with the class. But knowing that the survival spec uses Cobra Shot instead of Steady Shot to regain focus and therefore a survival hunter glyphing Steady Shot (a shot never used by survival) is essentially the same as an empty glyph slot would be a good idea. Whether they are using the optimal glyphs should not be your concern. This allows for rather sophisticated parses of basic competence (not theorycrafting debates) while not requiring one or a few people to understand every class.

The reasons I do not think it is wise to let this turn into an evaluation of game play/raid performance are two-fold:

One, it puts the focus of individual raiders in the wrong place during raids. The only way to even remotely be able to critique the play of a fellow raider is to watch them play, consistently. You may get flashes of other people in your raid while you're killing dragons, but your focus should be very much focused on your own play, not on evaluating another person.

Secondly, and more importantly, not everyone is good at or interested in communication. To put it more frankly, a lot of people are jerks. Giving them the sanctioned ability to tear into someone else is a bad idea. Gameplay is to some extent opinion-based, and everyone has an opinion---and many people express their opinions in a non-ideal way. The character audit is not meant to be opinion-based. It's meant to be largely a question of facts: either a piece of gear is gemmed and enchanted or it isn't. Either the glyphs empower abilities that that spec uses, or they don't (again, no comments on whether they are the "right" glyphs...only whether all the glyph spots are used and pertain to the abilities that spec uses). It probably could be boiled down to a checklist, and it removes opinion from the equation. Leave overall performance evaluation (in the numbers and in handling mechanics) to the raid leadership--hopefully individuals chosen because they have good communication skills among other things. 

The main idea behind this system is that a raid is a collective endeavour and everyone "owes" doing their best, within their time constraints, to make it successful. This system should not be uncovering failures every week. That is not what it is about. It's about recognizing that everyone has a responsibility to everyone else, that the raid group is always fully aware of all matters relevant to the raid group and therefore each individual is accountable for carrying out that responsibility. Ideally, this system will encourage people to ensure that their gear/glyphs/gemchants are always in good shape, so that they don't get red flagged by their auditor, and the audits are passed week after week...leading to a smooth raid week after week.

Saturday, May 7, 2011

We Talking About Practice?

"We're sitting here, and I'm supposed to be the franchise player, and we're talking about practice. I mean listen, we're sitting here talking about practice, not a game, not a game, not a game, but we're talking about practice. Not the game that I go out there and die for and play every game like it's my last but we're talking about practice man. How silly is that?" -- Allen Iverson, former NBA star


I've floated this idea before, in various venues, but I thought I'd write a little piece about it here. It would be nice to have "practice instances." A version of each of the level-cap instances (dungeons and raids) that are meant only for training purposes. You can enter solo or with other people and the missing slots are filled with NPCs. A role check ensues and whatever roles you (and any friends) don't assume are assumed by the NPCs.

These practice instances would not drop any loot, any currency, any gray items...nothing. There would be no material benefits. No reputation gains, either. Perhaps no durability loss to deaths, but I can go either way on this. Blizzard has to decide whether another gold sink is needed in the game.

The purpose would be to practice either playing your class/role or handling encounter mechanics, or both. And doing so without the social pressures of wondering whether you will be attacked for a mistake and not wanting to disappoint others if you do make mistakes.

Now, obviously, if you want the rewards (valor points, purples, esteem from arrogant stone giants) of running instances, you need to accept the social pressures. Running instances is meant to be a social activity. However, it seems reasonable to allow players to practice free of social pressures. This seems especially true of someone trying to learn a new role. If you leveled up a paladin in retribution, and then later decide you'd like to try your hand at tanking...it can be rather daunting to do so before the eyes of four critical strangers, over and over again.

This would be a benefit for both the learner as well as the population at large. Very few people enjoy queuing for a random and getting someone who's still learning how to tank or heal. The many, many mistakes lead to a lot of deaths. But there's no good way to learn tanking or healing outside of instances. You can understand the concept and theories quite well, but the actual execution in the dynamic heat of battle is quite different.

The idea of NPCs trying to emulate players might seem like a reach. After all, there are very few AIs that have reached human levels of intelligence, and they're all currently unemployed (it's a tough job market). However, end game content, to a large extent, has players function like robots. I don't mean that in a disparaging way, but handling encounter mechanics is a very synchronized, repeatable process and the design of DPS, tanking and even healing can be formalized into rules that would allow an NPC to do a pretty good impression of a competent human. Most of the challenge is processing information and reaction time, both of which computers do better than humans (and Blizzard would actually have to be careful not to make them overpowered).

Blizzard could even have these NPCs occasionally print Recount stats to party line, toss in a "LOL" occasionally or a "srsly blizz? omg" and it would feel just like an instance with real people. Except you'd have the comfort of knowing that there's no judgement behind those cold, dead, pixelated eyes.

I think this would go a long way to improving the skills and confidence of the player base, which would lead to improved results in the actual random dungeon finder. Plus it would just be fun. Sometimes, even when I'm not learning an encounter or a role, I just want to experiment with something...it would be nice not to subject real people to it.

So, in conclusion, I'm very generous with Blizzard's time and resources and I encourage them to program this functionality.

Monday, April 25, 2011

Confessions Of A (Former) Altaholic

Leading into Cataclysm and early in Cataclysm's wake, I read a few perspectives that essentially called Cataclysm the "golden age of alts." The idea was that if ever there was a time to start throwing yourself into playing other characters, this was the expansion to do it.

On the surface, that made sense. There were two new races (complete with their own starting areas), new heirlooms, guild perks to smooth out leveling and areas redesigned to streamline the questing experience. Even lower level dungeons had been redesigned to breathe new life into them.

How to resolve, then, that I went the other way? I was a pretty significant altaholic during my time in Wrath. After leveling my main up to 80 around October of 2009, I leveled four more characters up to 80 over the next year--a shaman, hunter, mage and priest (who became my main, relegating my original paladin to "alt" status, but that's neither here not there) in addition to a druid that languished at about level 72 due to the end-of-expansion blues. Beyond that, I dabbled in more characters of other classes, sometimes deleting them as high as level 50, 60 or 70 because I wanted to make something new. I played a lot of characters when I wasn't raiding on my main.

Now, however, I've become very alt-averse. While I've leveled up most of my level 80 characters to 85, it was in a more desultory manner. A might-as-well mindset rather than real interest. My priest is my main and my shaman could almost be thought of as a co-main. I raid on both of them a lot and as seriously as I can, which is how I define a "main" character. As for my other eight characters? I only play my rogue with any real interest and even then only to level it in a very casual, slow manner (it's 66 at the moment). So I could argue that, in practice, I only have one alt I'm interested in.

So, from my perspective, was Wrath the "golden age of alts?" Not exactly. That was going to be the thrust of my post, but when I began thinking it over, I realized the true root of why I played them so actively then and not now. And the answer didn't lie in the specific nature of the latest expansion of the time.


Fading Light Gleams Golden


The answer is that the final year of an expansion is easy money for an alt. With previous tier gear available for justice points (known as emblems of valor by that point in the previous expansion) and those points easy to farm in heroics that most people overgeared massively. With raid teams able to mount more alt runs and PUG raids available. With the top-of-the-line enchants and gems no longer new and their prices down. With all of these factors, it was quick and easy to get a fresh level 80 raid-geared and into raids within a couple of days, and without abdicating the other priorities in your life to do it.

Now, this is a very end-game-centric view. For me, the only real enjoyment to the game is end-game raiding with people I enjoy playing with (though I also can enjoy running dungeons with friends, but that is more for the social aspect rather than the game aspect). So the only thing that makes playing an alt attractive is raiding with a new class. Every moment of the leveling-up and gearing-up process is a zero from an enjoyment point of view. It's an effort investment to have fun once it's done. The fun at the end has to outweigh the time spent getting there, or else the books fail to balance.

In Wrath, with five fewer levels to acquire and raid-worthy gear so quick to pick up, the accounting finished easily in the black.


You Mean I Have To Earn It? No Deal, Man!


However, Cataclysm has changed the math significantly. There are, as noted, five extra levels to acquire (this is mitigated to some extent by the faster rate of xp gain possible and the lowering of the xp needed for levels 70-80). More importantly, the gearing-up process is far from trivial now. Reputation items matter (by the next tier, they won't, since they'll be outdated compared to justice point gear and dungeon drops) so pencil in four to six reputation grinds. Justice point farming involves running heroics that are still challenging, which ups both the play time and effort as well as the social cost (when dungeons are challenging, there's more adversity, which leads to more negative personalities expressing themselves). Gems are actually not very expensive at all, but the top-line enchants are almost prohibitively so unless you're excellent at earning gold (and even for those good at it, making a lot of gold has its own time cost). Raid teams, outside of the harder-core guilds, are still struggling with content and are not deploying as many alt raid teams. PUG raids are very uncommon for anything outside the toy raid of Baradin Hold.

So now I find that the time and effort necessary is no longer worth the payoff. It's going to take me longer and require more work to get an alt to acceptable levels of raid readiness and in the end, I may not even have a raid spot for that character. This is not a complaint, at all, just an observation as to why Cataclysm's advent hasn't resulted in a surge of interest in playing alts for me and, in fact, has had the opposite effect.

I do put in a lot of effort to keep my main(s) in top form for raids and in the actual raiding. I just don't want to apply that same level of effort over three or four or five or ten characters.

I'm sure that the final year of Cataclysm will be pretty nice for (my) alts, though! Perhaps even the next tier of content will provide the easy access to alt raiding that will make all the zero-gain (for me) time of leveling and gearing worthwhile. Once it's fairly quick to get multiple alts into raids, I'm so there!

Until then, my rogue will take the scenic route to the level cap and perhaps take some time off to bum around Europe and maybe acquire a classical liberal arts education.

Monday, April 18, 2011

Raiders Don't Eat Quiche (But Maybe They Should?)

World of Warcraft has a long and fine culinary history and it's for more than just show...cooking has become intertwined with the actual play aspect, as food is an important consumable for running end-game instances, especially raids.

However, Blizzard appears to take the position that only meat and fish can get a fine blood lust (not Bloodlust[tm]) going in people. While I fully appreciate the powers of protein, characters are probably getting enough protein from all the non-buff food that they can be assumed to be eating to fuel their metabolism for all the non-instanced activity they engage in. It's also to be expected that characters are mostly carnivorous. To my eye, the lands of World of Warcraft are significantly less agrarian than our real world.

Fruits and vegetables obviously have virtues, as well, though. Why shouldn't we have some vegetarian buff foods in addition to the meat- and fish-based ones? Let me be clear: I'm nothing even remotely resembling a vegetarian in real life. This is not a "Blizzard, validate my life choice!" rant. This is just something I thought about and thought was fun.

Currently, buff foods mostly come from fish and meats, which require farming. Now...where might we find vegetable matter that can be farmed? Herbalism? That was my first thought...why not allow for cooking recipes that require herbs? Of course, the main drawback to this is that any character can pick up fishing or kill beasts that drop tasty meats. Any character cannot pick up herbalism, as not everyone wants to be an herbalist. It may not be ideal to have some foods depend on a primary profession.

But Blizzard could always institute a pseudo-herbalism. Humans (and humanoids) are inherently hunter/gatherers. Currently, most of our gathering is strictly the gathering of loot(z). Why not be able to gather fruits and vegetables? Blizzard could create a new set of nodes that are based on a secondary profession to gather. I don't have a good name for it, at the moment. Like fishing, you'd skill it up through gathers (though fewer gathers per skill point, since you're not able to sit in one spot to do it) and higher level fruits and vegetables could be used in higher level foods.

And if Blizzard ultimately wanted to incorporate herbalism into it, I don't think it would really be a problem. Food is never soulbound and most people don't skill up fishing on every character they play. Just as you may have a fishing character who sends the fish or the completed food to your raiding main, you could have an herbalist character who sends the herbs or the completed food to your raiding main. And if you just refuse to skill up herbalism on any character (I just did it the other day, it took less than two days to do!), there's always the auction house.

Some foods, maybe even more powerful ones, might use both fish/meat and herbs. Wow! Fancy. I hope I didn't just blow your mind with the complexity implied here.

I think it would add one more (slight) level of depth and a little bit more fun. One more way to do the things you already do: grind, make stuff, kill bosses.

On the other hand, maybe it's pointless because why add another thing to grind and make, when all we want to do is kill bosses?

Friday, April 8, 2011

Building Your Skills From Basics To Fine Polish

So, Khizzara, of [Blog of the Treant] wrote a very cool post building upon some things I wrote about earlier. Now, like the blog equivalent of a Prayer of Mending bouncing back and forth, I'm going to write a post inspired by what she wrote.

I very much enjoyed her recounting experiences as a vocalist and how practicing that can be applied to practicing healing. She then provided an excellent list of tips on how to proceed...and that list inspired me to try to formalize an approach to first reducing your toolkit to a manageable, but still usable, level and then adding layers of sophistication.

To some extent, this is for those who would like to start healing...but I think formalizing things can provide benefits even to those who are veterans. I am reasonably veteran as a healer, but I found this a useful exercise and it paid dividends when trying to raid at a high level with an alt healer of a new class.

Edit: Let me make a clarification at the outset, based on some feedback that I've received. This is not meant as a priority guide. The steps of this guide are not meant to display the order of your most important spells, nor your most used spells. That isn't the mapping I am aiming for. The idea was to create clusters of logically connected spells (in my opinion, of course) that don't create an overload of concepts at any one time but hang together reasonably successfully. Once you understand your entire toolbox, you should be discovering for yourself which spells are most effective for you to use most often and when to employ them. This guide is meant to ease you into your toolbox in what I view as the simplest way while still getting you into your entire toolbox.


Reduce Your Toolkit To Only The Needful


Forget your longer cooldowns. Go on, just forget them. They don't exist. They're gone. (By "longer cooldowns," I mean anything longer with a cooldown that is more than around 30 seconds.)

Cooldowns will be important, but they're an added level of complexity that you don't need to start with.

Of your remaining spells, focus on three as your core:

1. Your slow, cheap, weak heal. This is Heal for priests, Holy Light for paladins, Healing Wave for shamans and Nourish for druids.

2. Your slow, expensive, big heal. This is Greater Heal for priests, Divine Light for paladins, Greater Healing Wave for shamans and Healing Touch for druids.

3. Your fast, expensive, moderately large heal. This is Flash Heal for priests, Flash of Light for paladins, Healing Surge for shamans and Regrowth for druids.

With just these spells, you can conceivably heal a Cataclysm dungeon on normal mode. And if you're just starting out, you should start in a normal, no matter your gear level, just to get acquainted with your spells. It's not optimal to just use these three spells, but they are robust enough to get the job done in a normal dungeon. In a heroic, it would be very difficult to use just these spells...but even then, it's possible if the tank marks kill order, CC is applied and everyone does their job. So, on second thought, no, it's impossible.

These three spells, though, can be practiced outside a group setting, sitting in Orgrimmar or Stormwind. Get thee to the training dummies, injure yourself (hop on your flying mount, fly up a little and dismount) and attack a dummy to ensure you're using combat mana regen and not out-of-combat regen. The main thing is to get a sense for how fast the spells "feel" (numbers are numbers, but as I said in a previous post, you need to develop a feel), their effect on your health and their effect on your mana pool. Experiment and get a sense for how much each can be "spammed" and effective mixes of each spell that allow you to maintain your mana pool for different lengths of time.


Adding A Layer Of Complexity: Flavor


So you understand your core, the spells you can always fall back on. However, the real power of healers comes with the spells that they can sprinkle in around the core. Spells that are meant to be used regularly but aren't meant to be spammed nonstop. I call the the "flavor spells." These spells give each healing class their unique flavor.

Let's look at the most commonly used flavor spells.

Priests have two specs, discipline and holy. Discipline is going to be making heavy use of Power Word: Shield and Penance, while Holy is going to be making heavy use of Renew and Circle of Healing. Both specs should be utilizing Prayer of Mending whenever possible.

Druids have a few spells that could fit into this category, but I'm going to suggest focusing on three of them to start with: Wild Growth, Lifebloom and Swiftmend (be sure to notice the Efflorescence effect from your talents).

Paladins have Holy Shock, Word of Glory and Beacon of Light as key flavor spells.

And finally, our shaman wolves have Chain Heal, Riptide and Earth Shield.

Let me take a moment here to clarify something: This is not a "how to heal as a paladin/druid/shaman/priest" or even a "how to heal" piece. I certainly have my opinions on that, and there is a ton of content on the internetz on those topics. My aim here is to help you narrow your focus at first and then gradual widen your scope as a healer, as it regards your toolbox. So I won't be going through how precisely to use each of those abilities. I've simply highlighted the spells that, in my opinion, you should be focusing on as your "next layer" after mastering your three core heals.

So really study the tooltips on those spells for your class and glance through your talents for any additional effects that your talents might provide for any of those spells (I gave an example of one for the druidic arts). Get a solid sense of what each of those spells and think about when each spell would be most useful and when it would be least useful. For example, Chain Heal: this is clearly maximized when four injured targets are within the spell's jump range of each other. This spell is minimized when just one person is hurt (leaving out the trivial case, in almost every spell's case, of no one at all being hurt).

That's an easy and obvious example, but going through each spell and really understanding when it's maximized and minimized builds structure in your mind that you can apply to novel situations. If one or two people are hurt, that's too close to the minimization scenario of chain heal, so you don't need to spend time calculating the healing you'll do versus the mana and time you'll spend...you can guess immediately that it's not the best spell and not use it. Five people are hurt? Well, that's very close to the maximization scenario, so fire it off and see where you are after that. You don't want to get stuck, as I've explained in a previous post, cogitating on what spell to cast next, weighing the pros and cons and mathing it out. You have to have a "feel" for what comes next. Forcing yourself to identify simple characteristics of each spell you have, like maximization and minimization scenarios, helps you develop that feel.

Weave these spells in around your core heals. Always fall back on your core heals when you're unsure of what to do but you know you must do something. Stay on the look out for good opportunities to use your flavor spells. Your core heals are trusty vanilla...your flavor spells add the sparkling sprinkles whenever the situation calls for more than vanilla. Swirl them into the cool delicious....mmmm, ice cream.... what were were talking about again?

You now have six spells in your arsenal, acquired through two steps. Neither step involved learning a large contingent of spells. Further, you now have enough in your active toolbox to heal a heroic. It will be hard, especially at first, but you have the tools to get it done. You aren't maximizing the potential of your class yet, of course, and the result is that some people will die that wouldn't have if you had mastery of every spell...but trying to jump in and effectively use ten spells that are new to you, in the fast-paced environment of heroic dungeon healing, will likely lead to more deaths and potentially some trauma for you. A lot of people try to pick up a new role and, not being sure of what to focus on, use everything badly, feel like a failure and quit. Don't let that happen to you!


The Filler Spells


I feel bad. I've given some very great and noble spells a pretty lousy name. "Filler"...as if they were the pork anuses and chicken snouts that fill in your hotdog. I couldn't think of a more dreamy name for them that was usefully descriptive, though. These are the spells that you should be turning to when you've internalized the above six spells and can use those six spells quickly without having to think much. They should bore you, like a teenager who can parallel park and and drive from stoplight to stoplight without incident. "Give me more, man!" you should be thinking. "Let me open this thing up on the open road and slice through the wind like a...wind-slicing...thing. That goes fast." That is what you should be thinking if you're moving on to the next step.

So get a load of these spells, spells that fill in the gaps around your core heals and flavor spells. They occupy niches and are unlikely to be spells you want to use constantly, usually for mana reasons. But not always.

Priests should be eying Prayer of Healing and Binding Heal.

Paladins should study Holy Radiance and Light of Dawn.

Shamans should research Healing Rain and Unleash Elements.

Druids should scope out Rejuvenation and, um...that's all. Hey, what can I say...some classes have slightly smaller toolboxes than others.

Some of these spells are used more often, some are used less often. Mana cost, length of cooldown and effectiveness will dictate to you how often you use them, but none are essential to making it all the way through a dungeon. All of them are essential to maximizing your healing potential, which will keep deaths to a minimum in a dungeon setting and will matter a great deal whenever you decide to hit the raiding circuit. So once you're very comfortable with your Core Heals and Flavor Spells, start mixing in some Filler Spells. Every great chef will tell you that the best dishes require some filler.*

*May not be true of many, or any, great chefs.


Hey, Cool Down, We're Not Done Here


Remember those long cooldowns I told you to forget? Something about them being gone? Well, they're back. In pog form.

Cooldowns are the final frontier of the healing game. It's where good healers become elite and elite healers discover they can do more with their lives than wasting it playing World of Warcraft. Cooldowns, to put it another way needlessly, are where you take it to another level.

This is not for beginners. These spells take uncommon flair, brilliance and subtlety of mind. The uninitiated, the unready, can have their minds warped just as surely as gazing unprepared upon the home world of Cthulu*. Needless to say, we're getting into serious juju here.

*Cthulu is my neighbor's dog. My neighbor's apartment is positively filthy. I shudder to even think about it.

Holy priests need to figure out Chakra and what it converts your Holy Word spell into.. Discipline priests need to wrap their minds around Power Word: Barrier. Both species of priests need to master the fine art of singing away the hurt: Divine Hymn and Hymn of Hope.

Paladins, well, you have about a thousand types of Hand spells and Protection spells. Often they're named the same with little accent marks differentiating them. Learn them, live them, employ them. And don't forget Lay on Hands. Or Avenging Wrath. Or Guardian of Ancient Kings. Or Divine Plea. So, basically, paladins don't heal, they merely cooldown. Or something.

Druids have Tranquility and Tree of Life. And, technically, Rebirth. They also have Nature's Swiftness if they choose (so do shamans...Blizzard's design team sometimes needs an afternoon off, after all).

Shamans, in addition to having the aforementioned druid cooldown if they choose to take that talent, have Spiritwalker's Grace. (I'm not going to get into the non-healing-related cooldowns, so Tremor Totem and Bloodlust will not be mentioned. At all. Besides, if I mentioned Bloodlust, then I'd have to field complaints from weirdos who call it "Heroism." Best not to rile those people.)


Okay, We're Done Here (i.e. The Big Finish)


I have not hit on every single spell a healer might employ. This isn't meant to be a complete compendium of healer spells for each class. I've largely included the ones that feature the most, but you should dig around in your spellbook and look at talents and figure out other creative applications of spells. I haven't even gone into Atonement healing for discipline priests (smite your friends to better health)  or Telluric Currents mana regeneration for shamans (lightning bolts are weaponized mana).

The main idea here is to start small and build larger and larger towers of healing expertise. I tried to lay out a logical plan for where to start and how to grow. This may work for you or it may not. The general concept is paring down to essentials and building from there, ensuring that you always have enough tools to survive but not more than you absolutely need at each phase of development.

However, you may be the type that likes to put everything in your spellbook on your bars, queue up and see what happens. If that is you, I salute you. We can't all drink Mountain Dew, though.