Showing posts with label design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label design. Show all posts

Saturday, July 21, 2012

Chakra: The Worst Clever Idea Blizzard Ever Had

Frequent readers probably realize that I play a priest as my main character. Most of my priesting life has been as discipline, but I've been playing a fair amount of holy since patch 4.3 dropped (I also flirted with it off and on in Wrath, but that experience isn't going to be relevant to this post) and the most iconic element of holy priest play (for the priest herself, anyway) is Chakra. This is the device around which the entire spec is supposed to, and does, turn.

Let's start with the good: Chakra was a great idea, conceptually. The idea of being able to fluidly shift from one "healing stance" to another, as needs and circumstances dictate, is a great idea and definitely was unique to the World of Warcraft healing game. It was to be the shining concept that, as Ghostcrawler put it, made people want to spec holy.

And, if it worked, it probably would have been successful in that goal. 

However, the concept is fundamentally and fatally flawed in a game built around balance and a "bring the player, not the class" design principle. It's a device that puts designers in a catch-22, where the solution to one problem creates another problem and the solution to that problem creates the original problem.

The reason for this is that there exist, broadly, only two ways to balance a device like Chakra, which allows priests to choose between two* mutually exclusive stances: one that empowers raid, or area of effect (AoE) healing and one that empower single-target healing. These stances are Sanctuary and Serenity, respectively

*Forget Chastise stance, it's irrelevant in group PvE content

Option 1: You balance the priest such that when she is in Sanctuary Chakra, she is just as good at AoE healing as the other four (soon to be five) healing specs and when she is in Serenity Chakra, she is just as good at single-target healing as the other four/five healing specs. However, to make choosing a stance meaningful, the priest must be worse at the type of healing she is not in Chakra for, which creates the problem. In order to be just as good as any other healing spec at one type of healing, she must necessarily be worse than all the other healing specs at the other type of healing (it's not possible, nor even feasible even if it were possible, to shift Chakra states prior to each healing spell and it is not uncommon to need to sometimes cast some single-target healing spells while mostly AoE healing and vice versa). If the holy priest has 100% / 75% effectiveness (for the two types of healing) compared to the 100% / 100% effectiveness of all the other specs, the holy priest is clearly underpowered. She is significantly less flexible, for no added benefit over the other healing specs, who can do everything with no penalty.

So...

Option 2: Let's solve that by giving holy priests a benefit. Let's make them stronger than every other healing spec in the type of healing they are in Chakra for, to balance out being weaker in the type of healing they are not in Chakra for. To put it simplistically (just to illustrate the concept, not be mathematically rigorous right here), if the holy priest is at 125% / 75% (for the two types of healing) effectiveness compared to the 100% / 100% effectiveness of all the other healing specs, that's balanced...mathematically. However, now the flexibility problem swings in the other direction. The holy priest is far too versatile. Any competitive raiding team will feel pressured to bring nothing but holy priests for their healing team, because a holy priest can always be the best at whatever the team needs at any given time.

You can craft a contrived, complicated system of healing involving Chakra that requires an immense skill cap, whereby an amazing holy priest can use Chakra to always be the best performer at the cost of having to work much harder than every other healing class. But, leaving aside whether that would even be fun, healers who are willing to work as hard will feel burned that they can't produce the same results with other classes.

Ultimately, this is very akin (though not identical) to the druid "bearcat" problem that Blizzard finally plans to resolve in Mists of Pandaria by splitting bear druids and cat druids into separate specs. Blizzard realized that it was a fundamentally impossible problem to solve when the two were differentiated only by a form change: either they had to gut one form, or they had to allow feral druids to be overpowered in terms of potential utility. While the specifics aren't identical, it similarly illustrates that you cannot allow a significant change in powers from something that can be switched in combat. It's impossible to find an acceptable state, where the class-spec that can shift its powers mid-combat is neither significantly underpowered nor significantly overpowered. It's not a matter of tuning numbers...the solutions lead to problems who's solutions lead back to the original problem.

To re-iterate, I think Chakra was a great idea, a very cool concept. If you could shift your healing powers while remaining in balance with everyone else, it would have absolutely been the shining reason to play holy. As it stands, it merely feels punitive...and the solution to that would be to punish every other healing class-spec in the game for not being a holy priest.

Sadly, it's time for a new device, a new centerpiece, for holy priests.


Sunday, June 26, 2011

(Will I Still WoW) When I'm Sixty Four?

I was recently pondering* which was of bigger importance in my life: World of Warcraft or music? The way I decided to evaluate it was, which would I eliminate from my life forevermore, if I had to?

*I was pondering it because I decided to start a music blog, since I enjoy blogging and music is my other great enjoyment. The blog is located at http://havethestoneskilled.wordpress.com/. That is, of course, a shameless plug but only click the link if you're interested in music and my thoughts on said music. I'm not trying to generate stray clicks.

The answer, pretty easily, was World of Warcraft. Part of that, however, was that I expect music to be important to me all my life whereas it's kind of hard to imagine still playing World of Warcraft when I'm 80 years old (rather an understatement). In fact, will World of Warcraft even exist in ten years, when I turn 80?


So Let's Change The Question


Instead of comparing World of Warcraft (which is a single game and will assuredly not last for many years) to music, how about MMOs in general to music? To this point in my life, it's one and the same, as I am not an "MMO player," I am a "WoW Player." I'm really not much of a gamer...you could almost draw a straight line from my Nintendo-playing days as a kid to Prince of Persia in the 1990s to World of Warcraft in terms of my commercial games-playing history. It's sparse.

That said, World of Warcraft has definitely captured me. It's a very big part of my life now, and I can certainly imagine moving to another MMO whenever WoW reaches the end of its run of relevance, which is inevitable (even Blizzard is preparing for a post-WoW reality by developing its new MMO, codenamed Titan).

So the real question is, what about WoW is it that has enthralled me so thoroughly and, therefore, what would need to exist in the future to make it likely that I'll remain addicted to playing MMOs in the way that I am (seemingly) irrevocably hooked to music?


The MMO Magic


There are three main components that attract me to playing World of Warcraft and at least two of them don't seem even remotely close to optimized in my view.

  • Character As Self Expression : Any time you create an avatar, whether it's an icon and profile on a discussion forum or a virtual person in a game, you are representing something of yourself in it (unless you are filling out all the fields purely randomly). It stands to reason that you can therefore use the character in a game as a form of self expression. The more you can customize it to your tastes, the more of your creative being is being expressed.
  • Social Connections : Obviously, a major part of an MMO is the "massively multi-player" portion of the acronym. It's a world not just in terms of virtual geography but in terms of society. There are a whole lot of people to potentially meet, in addition to any friends you knew prior to the game that you now have a new way to relate to. Playing with other people, socializing with other people is a big part of the power of these games.
  • Challenging, Skill-Based Combat : This can be achieved in various ways but the way that World of Warcraft achieves it is through either Player versus Player games or Player versus Dragon encounters (that's right, PVD...that's what playing a fantasy game does, and should, boil down to!). I'm not much for PVP, but I just adore PVD (okay, okay, PVE).

Blizzard does a pretty damn solid job of the third one, in my opinion. It's not inconceivable that it could be better, but there are no glaring flaws with the end-game, in my opinion.

The second aspect is kindof there by default. I don't think Blizzard does a whole lot to maximize the social aspect of the game...which is fine. Blizzard has limited resources in terms of spending time to expand the game and there are a wealth of other ways people can connect on the Internet. Blizzard correctly prioritizes the game aspect to work on.

The first one is a trainwreck for a game of World of Warcraft's magnitude, in my view. You are supposed to feel attached to your character(s) and desire to progress with them, but the opportunities to set them apart from cookie-cutter archetypes are few and far between. The character creation process is surprisingly limited, there's virtually no ability to choose how you want to look from a fashion standpoint and all melee essentially have the same animations as do all casters. Essentially, your only in-game ability to look different is to choose from the tiny selection of hair styles not offered at the character creation screen and tabards. That's about it.

But I didn't write this post to vent about WoW. I came to praise it, didn't I? This is the game that, taken as a package, I love. Isolating what makes the game fascinating to me helps me identify what a future game would need to have to potentially draw me in after WoW.


So Might Future Games Be Even More Addictive?


As computing power and connectedness increases, one can certainly imagine each of those aspects being expanded, honed and made more powerful. Leaving aside end-game content (as what makes fighting dragons fun is awfully subjective and the subject of game design, which I don't feel like getting into here), I think it's clear that the social and self-expression aspects can be increased substantially.

An MMO could allow players to hook their IM clients into the game, whereby whispers, chats, etc, go to an IM client window/tab...even if you are not currently in the game (if you so choose). If you meet someone and don't yet feel like exchanging e-mails or even more personal information, you could still socialize in and out of the game. You could follow guild chat discussions even when you don't have the time/inclination to run the game. It's a fairly simple idea and much more elaborate social immersion could be fashioned, but I'm not trying to paint a "Turn the galaxy into one big computer!" vision of the future...just a simple step forward meant to illustrate that there's more power here to be tapped.

At a very basic level, customization of a character can involve more than WoW allows. Body type selections when creating the character (does my elvish rogue really have to be body builder? Seriously, Blizzard). Clothing slots that allow you to wear a set of gear for looks without losing the benefits of the set of gear you need for dragon-slaying stats. And then of course there are the futuristic possibilities, like having a facial creation tool, allowing you to truly fashion a look that no one else will have. This is supposed to be the virtual you...you probably want to be more "you" (by which I mean, your tastes, not necessarily your real life looks) than one of the thousand human clones running around and disco dancing.


Still Music, Though


Even if I make the assumption that I will be playing MMOs and healing til the day I die in real life, it doesn't change my answer. Music is a bigger part of my life today than World of Warcraft is. I don't play much WoW every day...the two raid nights are where WoW really becomes a big deal. Music is important every day.

A future MMO would have to be a lot more compelling, pulling at my daily entertainment hours more strongly to compete with music. That said, MMOs do have quite a lot of potential to grow. I think World of Warcraft did a lot of things right and therefore rightfully jumped to a position of dominance. Now it remains to be seen whether this form of game stagnates and withers on the vine or is evolved further in next-gen iterations and makes the jump to overall life obsession.

Now if only I could marry the two and listen to music while I raid rather than to all those annoying guildies on Vent who want me to heal or something.

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Minimalism

Minimalism is a popular design term and aesthetic, but it seems to mean something rather different to a lot of different people. Generally when people talk about minimalism, they are referring to a design of theirs that has a varying amount of minimalism. This is fine, but let's flesh out exactly what minimalism is in its pure form, because it's a useful design technique even if a "pure minimalism" is not necessarily called for in what you're working on.


Distilling Minimalism To Its Essence


Here are the precise requirement for pure minimalism, so that we have a solid base to talk from:

1. Everything you need must exist
2. Nothing you don't need should exist
3. There should be no redundancy

I'll tackle these one at a time, though they may largely seem self-explanatory.

The first principle is probably the most important, because it's the one most frequently violated by those pursuing minimalism. Minimal design means finding a way to encapsulate all needed functionality in the smallest "footprint" (for the space in question, whether floor space or screen space or whatever else) possible. If you make a conventional chair but then remove one leg, you aren't exercising minimal design--you're making a bad, unbalanced chair. Unless, of course, you come up with a new design to get the same functional power out of three legs.

The second principle is the one that people think about most with minimal design and requires the least explanation. Anything that doesn't add necessary functionality must go!

Finally, you can technically adhere to both of those two principles and still break minimalism by, to put it simply, adding the same necessary functionality twice. One could argue that this is already implied in (2) because a second version of the same thing is not needed, but I like to make this point explicitly, because it's one of the easiest pitfalls for designers.


Minimalism In Your World Of Warcraft User Interface


Let's look at these principles applied to a customized UI.

The least-cluttered interface is also the quickest non-default UI to create. Hit Alt-Z and marvel at your clean, unfettered display of the game. "Perfect UI, right?" I ask rhetorically. "Of course not, don't insult my intelligence by rhetorically assigning me, the reader, such an absurd position," you respond with some asperity. "My apologies, that was a bit condescending, I suppose, and lazy, generic writing to boot," I allow cautiously.

Clearly, there are some rather vital pieces of information that a real UI must incorporate. Your resources, like health, mana, energy, rage, runic power, etc, are pretty important to monitor. Decisions are generally based on the state of these resources and none of our brains are set up to process in-game events to precisely keep track of those resources in our heads. The resources of the enemies that we're fighting are also vitally important, because many of our decisions are made based on the state of those enemies. While this may seem like stating the obvious, and is obvious in these examples, this is the type of analysis one needs to do in determining what is necessary and what is not. What decisions are made based on the piece of information? How important are those decisions? How quickly do those decisions need to be made to be valuable? Are they in-combat decisions, or can they be made out-of-combat?

You can start from a cluttered interface and pare down, or start from a blank(-ish) slate and work your way up. Either way, you need a process for determining what is essential.

Once you've done that, principle two is pretty easy to execute: everything else needs to go.

Principle three is the final pass you need to make. Is any piece of information duplicated? This can be as simple as having both a player frame displaying your health and a raid frames add-on that includes you, therefore showing your health in two places (more on this later, though). Do you have your opponent's debuffs displayed in addition to Power Auras that give you visual alerts for the key debuffs you need to watch? In order to be perfectly minimal, you want to pare away the duplications.


Is Pure Minimalism Good?


So congratulations on your perfectly minimal design. It has every piece of information you require to do your job correctly, it has absolutely nothing that isn't essential and no information is duplicated. It was a grind but success is sweet.

Or is it? (Masterful twist.) Are you happy with this super-minimal UI? Everything's there, but is it easy to quickly process and translate into action? Does it look nice?

In the end, minimalism is a concept and aesthetic...it is not always, or even often, a desirable destination in its pure form. Maybe having a larger player frame in addition to your raid frames is a good thing. You may be able to customize your raid frames to show mana bars, but maybe the resulting mana bar in your raid frame box is too small to easily see. Maybe it's simply more important to see your own health than everyone else's and making your health exactly as visible as everyone else's costs you precious split-seconds in making a decision. Maybe you just think it looks nicer to have a proper player frame to create visual balance next to your target's frame. These are all examples of perfectly valid reasons to break away from a purely minimalistic design.

It's good to keep minimalism in mind. The cleaner and simpler your interface is, the less it will get in your way...to a point.Make it too minimal (and this still means in accordance with the principles laid out above) and it can start to get in your way again, by making it harder for you to process that necessary information. I think it's valuable to understand what, precisely, minimalism is...but a UI should balance minimalism, attractiveness and ease of use. There are often trade-offs to be made between those three things and what the right balance of those things are for you will be different than for someone else.

Final pro tip: Reduce all fonts in your UI to an unreadable 4 pt and bask in the minimal glory!