Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Love Poems To Priest Spells

Oh yes, it's that time again. This time, the object of my affection is Binding Heal.

Oh, Binding Heal
You always know how I feel
When I'm not hurt
You remain inert
Because your mana efficiency is just so poor.

However, when I'm in trouble
And unable to simply bubble
You provide me the link
Without being a mana sink
To keep me alive without my assignment hitting the floor.

My love, you are heaven sent
When adds attack with murderous intent
I can cast you with impunity
Before the tank has full threat, you see
You are such a paragon of virtue, you refuse to be an aggro whore.

For all these reasons and more
Binding Heal, you I adore.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

The Problem With Meters

It's been said so often that it's cliché: Healers cannot be properly be measured by meters (like Recount, Skada, World of Logs, etc).

What is perhaps less discussed is why that's the case, though everyone has a vague sense that healing is not purely about numbers (nothing is purely about numbers, but DPS is maybe a little closer to it).

Therefore and hence, I have decided to chat a little about this topic and explicate my own ideas on what makes for a good healer.


Your Assignment Doesn't Die


This is not so much insight as it is the most basic requirement. First and foremost, if you've been given an assignment, you keep that assignment alive for as long as necessary to win (bonus points if they survive the encounter, but winning's the thing). It's great if you can help out with other targets that another healer is struggling with (thereby boosting both your real value and metered value)...but if your assignment dies as a result, your real value drops like the corpse of what used to be your buddy (while your metered value doesn't take a hit).

You can see, then, the first approach to answering why meters can provide an inaccurate view of the action: losing your assignment really doesn't affect your numbers. But it sure affects your chances of winning. And every member's value is tied to how much they assist in defeating an encounter.

So always focus on your assignment (even to the exclusion of yourself, if "yourself" is not a part of your assignment unless you are on the verge of death)--trust your fellow healers and only help out if otherwise you'd turn into an onlooker because you have nothing else to do. Or if your fellow healer dies or goes out of mana and therefore is not available to trust.


Different Assignments Yield Different Numbers


Tank healing yields less healing numbers than raid healing. A tank requires less total healing, generally, than the rest of the raid. However, the tank generally needs more stressful, urgent healing. That's why different healing classes exist.

Unquestionably, Blizzard has brought all healing class-specs closer together in versatility. However, while any class-spec can potentially handle any assignment, certain class-spec toolkits shine more than others at specific tasks. You could ask a pastry chef to make some dinner entrées, and he or she would probably do a credible job, but why not have your, um, entrée chef (I'm clearly very knowledgeable about the chef scene) do them and have the pastry chef make desserts?

When you're assigned to healing a tank, here's an abstract description of your job: You will heal less but more urgently and swiftly when you do heal.

Similarly, the abstracted description of your job as a raid healer: You will heal near constantly, but in a more gradual and smoothly predictable manner.

The second job heals more. The first job heals more swiftly. They're equally valuable roles, but the raid healer (assuming strict adherence to roles, which is not always true and shouldn't always be the case) will generally out-heal the tank healer.


The Shape Of Healing Output Is Different By Class


Some class-specs are designed to be strongest at burst healing. Some are designed to be stronger at continuous healing. I often joke that the restoration druid in my raid is a "heal sniper" because her HoTs are always ticking, so they address small damage immediately, before I can heal. Her HoTs snipe a lot of healing, therefore she's bad and cheating me out of my numbers!

Well, not really, but it does help to illustrate the point. When I look at World of Logs, I see a few things:

  • My DPS (even healing is placed in a "DPS" context on WoL) is usually highest
  • My DPS(e) is usually lower than said restoration druid
  • My Active Time Percentage is always the lowest

The third point explains the difference between the first two. On World of Logs, DPS measures the healing/damage done when one is active (using a skill/spell) while DPS(e) simply divides your damage/healing done by the encounter length.

I'm not refusing to heal or unable to heal due to mana concerns. I heal when my assignment needs healing or when other targets seem to be unstable (the damage they're taking is not being easily handled by another healer). Small damage being tossed around I know will be addressed by things like Wild Growth, Healing Stream Totem, Healing Rain, etc. All those silly little heal snipers! Where I feel I shine, as a discipline priest, is providing bursts of healing when torrents of damage are hitting targets. Then I swing into action and my burst healing is pretty strong.

My fellow healers are not heal sniping and I'm not being lazy. We have different tools at our disposal and it doesn't make sense for me to try to rush in heals to beat a Wild Growth or a totem. Let those gradual, consistent heals soak up the gradual, small damage and be ready to blast away when someone's health suddenly spikes downward.


Utility Can Make Or Break Healer Contribution


As a discipline priest in Wrath, I used to say that I wasn't a healer, I was a shielder. This reflected the originally unnoticed and then more and more celebrated value of absorption that discipline priests brought...and the fact that end-of-expansion infinite mana pools made spamming shields far and away the most effective way to help the raid survive as a discipline priest.

Shield spamming is no longer the rule of the day, and discipline priests are no longer underrated due to the hazily understood value of absorption. Everyone understands the power of absorbs and now paladin healers and death knight tanks have horned in on the industry.

So I moved on to a new place to whine about how I am misunderstood: mitigation. That is, damage that is not healed nor absorbed, but lessened at the time it happens, like so. Or like this. Or even in this manner. Truly, I am the armor of faith.

But this section is not about mitigation (though I could talk for hours about mitigation) or even about the greatness of disco priests (I could talk for days, weeks and years about that). It's merely an example of healer utility that can be crucial to your effectiveness of play and yet won't be measured on meters (so far as I am aware).

Paladins have tons of utility, what with their many Hands and Shields. Shamans have the signature group/raid utility through their totems and druids bring Replenishment and can resurrect in combat (I would have mentioned Innervate but with the latest patch, it's largely been neutered as a tool to help others).

Maximizing the use of these non-healing, non-absorbing mechanics is a large part of what separates a passable healer from a high-level one, in my opinion. It won't make you look any better in the quantitative analysis, but it increases your raid's likelihood of winning an encounter. 


Stand In Fire, Burn Your Raid


Hey, we all stand in fire sometimes. Yes, even you. Sometimes it looks like fire and sometimes it looks like a wall of cyclones. It's still fire.


Everything pictured here = fire (image courtesy of Orcish Army Knife)


Of course, you want to minimize the amount of time standing in fire. Being a healer is not just healing, absorbing and utility-ing. It's also handling the mechanics of the combat and it's the final key component of being an excellent healer: raid awareness.

Being able to see your surroundings, process what's happening and what you need to be doing in terms of movement...all without losing any focus on your job, which is Healing (when capitalized, it folds in [small-h] healing, absorption, mitigation and utility). Moving may prevent you from Healing to your highest potential for a period, which means you need to plan ahead to decide either what measures to take to ensure your target doesn't need your best Healing while you're handling mechanics or else what measures to take later to recover.

Everyone needs raid awareness, but I think it can be most stressful for healers. DPS can often stop DPSing if they absolutely must, in order to get out of Dodge, without imperiling the raid. Tanks are all about raid awareness, but it's almost their entire job since in raids, threat is often an afterthought beyond the first thirty seconds or so.

Healers need to handle mechanics while actively healing non-stop and if they stop, people are at risk of dying. I am not attempting to suggest that healers have the toughest job in raids or that they are the noblest heroes/heroines in your raid (though if you've come to that conclusion on your own, I won't try to dissuade you), but I think they have the toughest row to hoe in balancing raid awareness with other things. It's not that important a point to what I'm saying, so I wouldn't really attempt to defend it more than I have above, but I think it is important to stress that healers evaluating their role and performance should be paying especial attention to how they balance healing with playing the specific encounter's mechanics.


So Are You A Good Healer Or, As The Kids Say, A Baddie?


Who knows? While I have some beliefs on what makes for a good healer, and why meters really won't answer the question, they're very hard or impossible to definitively analyze other than whether the healer keeps their assignment alive...and even failure on that account does not yield cut-and-dry conclusions, as it also depends on factors like A. whether it was a reasonable assignment to give a single healer, B. whether that healer's toolbox was well-matched to the assignment and C. whether that healer's assigned target did stupid things that can't be healed through.

Evaluating a healer is really more art (a euphemism for "bullshit" most of the time, unfortunately, and not just in regards to evaluating healers) than science. The numbers on the meter will give you an imprecise idea of the healer's throughput potential, but considering we're talking about "imprecise," "idea" and "potential," we can already see that nothing particularly conclusive will come of that, except at the extreme margins. If a healer is only putting out, say, 5k HPS they don't have the throughput for the current tier of content. If a healer is putting out 30k HPS (in a significant sample, not in 5 seconds of an encounter before dying), well, they're likely a pretty big asset to the raid.

But outside of somewhat obvious edge cases, everything else is in the murky middle where you're going to have to spend some time raiding with them, watching them a little and getting a feel for whether it seems like they're alert, making smart decisions and taking initiative at appropriate times. In some sense, it's a lot like evaluating a business executive: you can't compare her to the counter-factual universe in which she wasn't your executive, thereby giving you a basis for comparison. You simply have to develop a feel for the processes she's using to do her job and see whether the results are good over time: whether dragons are dying (as important a goal in the corporate world as in World of Warcraft).

If you're trying to evaluate yourself, I would suggest trying to improve along these vectors:

  • Is my assignment surviving to marry and settle down and have a family?
  • Am I being as proactive in using my mana as possible without trying to beat others to healing damage?
  • Am I using all my useful cooldowns?
  • Am I using those cooldowns at times when they'll do the most good?
  • Am I avoiding as much preventable damage as possible?
  • Am I communicating with my raid so that my actions support everyone else's?
  • Have I hidden my cloak and/or helm if they are intensely ugly?

As long as you're paying attention to your performance in these ways and always trying to improve your performance in these ways...then, to be honest, it doesn't matter whether you're a "good" healer or a "bad" healer. You're the best healer your skill and gear will allow and you'll find your natural level. That's all you can ask out of a game.

That and some options for body type at the character creation screen.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

The Triumphant Return Of Heal

In the first tier of raiding in Catalcysm, tier 11, I almost never used Heal. It was just too slow and weak. It was like a caster DPS blasting away with her wand. It will have some effect, but not enough to matter.

However, I'm noticing something interesting at the start of this new raiding tier: Heal isn't half bad. It's still much, much weaker than Greater Heal, Flash Heal and Penance...but it's actually useful now for a few reasons.


Heal Has Been Powered Up By Gear


One is that with gearing getting better, the speed of the heal is no longer crippling and the size of the heal now has the potential to move raid member's health bars (even if not by a huge amount).

"Sure," I hear you saying. "Heal is better with better gear. Big deal. Every heal is better with better gear, and everyone's health is increasing too. Holy Nova is better now, too. Time to use Holy Nova?"

No, of course not. Don't be silly. There's never a time to use Holy Nova unless it's to run around the Molten Front dailies, spamming it so that you get kill credit on everything.

However, throughput gains from intellect, haste, crit and mastery seem to be scaling with gear more than health pools (and, therefore, boss damage since boss damage output has to be firmly correlated with health pools*).

*Theoretically, boss damage output could be untethered from health pool size...but the only way for that to be viable would be if healing spell output were utterly massive, which would still mean Heal's output would outstrip health pool scaling and move life bars nicely.

Therefore, Heal is actually more powerful relative to this tier than it was relative to the last one. Sure, Flash Heal, Greater Heal and Penance will always do much more, but Heal is cheaper. Which means...


Healer Auto-Attacking (Or Wanding) Has Value


Any time damage is pouring in in a big way, you'll have other priorities, like the aforementioned bigger spells as well as Binding Heal and Prayer of Healing. But at the start of this tier, mana efficiency is going to matter again. Perhaps not quite so much as at the start of the last tier (since base mana didn't go up, so spell costs remained the same while mana pools are increasing) but with incoming damage higher, your larger mana pools will be challenged again.

And if you're a healing priest, Blizzard has a special gift for you: exactly zero of the cloth drops in the Firelands have spirit. That's not to say spirit doesn't exist for us; you can get spirit on valor point gear and there is spirit on some of the trinkets and jewelry (that every other healer will be after too)...but at least for a while, you may be packing fewer spirit pieces than you'd prefer.

Therefore, you want a tool that can have an effect without affecting your mana much. Enter Heal. The spell is at the very least mana neutral and may even be mana positive depending on your spirit levels and any mana regeneration tools occurring at the time (for example, Replenishment). By "mana neutral," I mean that you regain Heal's mana cost during the cast time and by "mana positive," I mean that you regain more than Heal's mana cost during the cast time.

This means you can still make a contribution essentially without expending mana or while (more slowly) regaining mana. This is useful during periods of low damage, to marshal your resources for the more intensive periods, and for when you run yourself right out of mana. Sure, being limited to Heal makes you a minor contributor at that point, but at least you're still in the fight rather than an interested onlooker.

Let's also remember that Blizzard's little surprise for healing priests (no cloth spirit drops) has a benefit: It means more pure throughput stats, since that stat budget has to be filled up one way or another. Now, until spell costs become completely trivialized, I'm a big believer that spirit is the best secondary stat because it can either give you mana regeneration when you need it, or can be converted into throughput when you don't. That said, spirit is definitely not better for pure throughput than mastery, haste or critical strike. Having more of those stats will make your Heal spell (in addition to all your others, of course) even stronger, allowing you in a strange sense to convert throughput stats into mana efficiency: You can cast more Heal and therefore conserve mana.


Critical Strike: Now With More Critical Goodness


As I'm sure you're aware, the latest patch brought with it a boost to all healers: critical heals now provide double the original output instead of one-and-a-half-times the original output. That means that when you drop in a critical strike Heal, you'll see a surprisingly large number. I've had Heal hit for 20k+ in heal-y deliciousness. That's pretty not bad for essentially no impact on my mana bar.

You can't count on a critical strike, but you can cast Heal on a target, hoping for a critical strike or two, until the target (or another target) is beginning to look a little green around the gills, in which case you can switch to bigger heals. A run of two or three critical strikes can result in fairly legitimate healing, leaving you awash in mana (which is blue and cooling to the mind and skin).


Tier 11 Two-Piece Bonus: How Ya Like Me Now?


It's still not exciting. That said, it's actually relevant now. I completely ignored the set bonus during the previous tier because I never cast Heal during raids, unless it was while fighting trash and everything was under control with little healing to be done. So the set bonus had no benefit at all for me.

Now, however, until you replace at least three pieces of your tier gear, this bonus will help. As we just noted, critical strike Heals can make a real difference and a 5% higher chance of getting them is a non-trivial effect. It seems like a small difference, our effectiveness is measured in a percentage here and a percentage there. It's a small chance for chaining a couple or three critical strike Heals together and those add up.


Bringing It All Home


Don't forget that Heal (like Flash Heal and Greater Heal) will reduce the duration of Weakened Soul, allowing you to get a Power Word: Shield back up on that target sooner. Similarly, Heal (like Flash Heal, Greater Heal and Binding Heal) has a chance to proc a free and instant Flash Heal if you have the Surge of Light talent. In both cases, Heal is a cheap way to take advantage of those talents, allowing you to more effectively use more powerful abilities.

The main thing to take away is not that Heal is suddenly an incredibly powerful tool. It isn't and is not meant to be. Rather, it's now a viable tool in the toolkit when raiding, rather than merely something to use when things are stable and boring in dungeons. You shouldn't be leaning on it, it shouldn't be a large part of your healing or usage...but it should be used now. It can provide value, essentially for free from a mana perspective. It's drawback is opportunity cost...it's a piece of time that you're not using to cast a more powerful spell. Most of the time, you can't afford that opportunity cost...but there are times when you should.

Casting Heal is like kissing your sibling. It's not generally recommended and feels a little shady. But in the right circumstances, especially with alcohol involved, it doesn't look half bad and everyone goes to sleep happy.

I can't see any flaws to that metaphor at all.

Friday, July 1, 2011

Discipline Priest Raid Healing

So my guild was working on Beth'tilac tonight (I'll end the suspense: we won) and while I was healing, my thoughts began to wander as they are wont to do (what else would I be doing while healing a raid encounter? Paying attention? Not likely!).

I began to think to myself, "Self, is this what it's come to, a discipline priest healing the raid?"

You see, our healer make-up was a discipline priest (your selfless protagonist), a restoration druid and a holy paladin. I prefer tank healing. But I feel that our holy paladin is best utilized tank healing and we only needed one dedicated tank healer...the healer that went up-web to heal the tank and DPS that broached the mighty spider in her lair.

So that left me and the druid earthbound, keeping everyone else alive. Sure, we have a tank too, but it felt like both of us needed to be covering the raid. Which left me in the position of needing to heal a lot of people.

Now, philosophically, this isn't something that bothers me. I tend to draw tank healing assignments these days, but in a previous guild (during Wrath), our healing team adopted a "see damage, heal damage" attitude. Not generally recommended, but we had a pretty strong rapport and didn't tend to overheal certain targets while failing to cover others. It seemed to work, at that time and place. In any case, the upshot is we were all raid and tank healers, so I've been quite used to watching everyone's health and responding.

However, I felt like perhaps I wasn't equipped for it. I do have a holy spec, and I picked it up for these eventualities, but I've encountered an obstacle in actually putting it to use. Raid damage is so fast and furious that you have to be fairly instinctive and I'm not instinctive in holy. I've never played it enough, since I've always loved the discipline style. And it's hard, I find, to practice. I could run five-mans, but what I've found is that it's nigh impossible to heal current heroics in holy's sanctuary (AoE) chakra stance. The tank damage is far too intensive (especially since crowd control has flickered back out of style) for AoE healing to keep the tank alive. You pretty much have to be in the serenity (single target) chakra stance. At least, that's how it feels for me, the inexperienced holy priest. And using serenity stance doesn't learn me up for raid healing in holy. If I were going to single target heal, I wouldn't use holy. I'd use discipline. But the chakra stance I'd want to use in raids doesn't feel viable in five-mans. Impasse.

Which brings us back to tonight and my thoughts. How to adapt discipline's tools to healing lots of people? I found a balance that worked for me, which I thought I'd lay out for those rare discipline priests pressed into raid healing.


Prayer Of Healing Heals A Lot Of People


I know, right? It's true: prayer of healing heals many (defined as five) people. This is where you start, when multiple (defined as three or more) people have taken 10-20% of their health in damage. The caveat, of course, is that they must all be in the same party.

Two things to note about this:

  • Have the Glyph of Prayer of Healing ready for an encounter where you'll be raid healing. And the Dust of Disappearance to switch it in. An extra 20% of the healing done as a HoT, on each person (even if the heal was overheal), is a pretty solid boon to getting people back up quickly.
  • Prayer of Healing automatically procs Divine Aegis on every person it hits, critical strike or not (and, again, overheal or not). If you crit, the Divine Aegis bubble is even larger. If damage is hitting the raid fairly continuously, that's just extra, free effective healing.
If you're reasonably well-geared for the current tier of raiding (~359 ilevel) with a good, solid amount of spirit, Prayer of Healing really won't strain your mana very much. It's not mana neutral, your mana will deplete...but quite slowly. As long as the damage coming in is only mild to moderate, this is your go-to heal. Insightful, I know; "Use your main AoE heal when...AoE healing."

I have more, though! Wait til the end of this post before you feel disappointed. Then you may feel as disappointed as you like.


Remember Whack-A-Mole? It's back! In POG form


That adapted Simpsons quote would have been so much cleverer if "POG" were an acronym for a key priest spell. Instead, it's just a reference shoe-horned in for the sake of a section title.

Still, the old healer favourite game of whack-a-mole is pretty apropos here. If people are taking more than 20% of their health in damage, it's time to abandon AoE heals for a whole new paradigm. That paradigm is called: You Have Ten Tanks So Go To Work, Tank Healer.

You could also call it "This is how you heal low level dungeons with tanks who can't hold aggro."

You pick the lowest health person and cast Greater Heal. Then you pick the new lowest health person and cast Greater Heal. You intersperse Penance whenever it's off cooldown (especially if you have the four-piece t11 bonus, which gives you a large spirit infusion whenever you cast Penance). You just keep rotating Greater Heals and Penances on whomever is closest to dying. Again, it's surprisingly mana efficient. You can pump out a lot of healing to a lot of people without endangering your mana too much.

You can, of course, add in some Flash Heals. Unlike at the start of Cataclysm, the world will not end if you cast that spell. If someone, especially someone important, is right...on...the verge...of dying, then throw them a lifeline with Flash Heal. Just make sure you don't fall into the temptation of casting it over and over. That will run you out of mana in a couple of minutes and very few raid boss encounters are that short. But as I've said before...it's better to use up all your mana and feel embarrassed about being out of mana than to wipe with mana left in the tank.


That Said...


Binding Heal is still your friend. Talk to it. Get to know it over a nice dinner. Keep it close to your heart, because it's the sweetest little heal in your arsenal when used properly.

It costs the same as Flash Heal...but it heals for almost twice as much. It's almost (but not quite) like casting a Flash Heal on yourself and another person...for the cost of a Flash Heal. And at the speed of casting one Flash Heal.

This is still going to run your mana down faster than Greater Heal or Penance, but its throughput cannot be matched. It's a Flash Heal that got an 80% output boost and 100% haste boost. That means it's essentially 3.6 times better throughput...at the same cost as Flash Heal.

The downside, obviously, is that you cannot choose the entire target of the healing. Half the healing goes on a target of your choice, half goes on you. But you can choose when to use it. If you're hurt, this is a great spell to lean on. The throughput is off the charts and the cost isn't terrible for what you get. It's a key weapon in the arsenal for healing multiple people. You're a person. You need healing. Remember that.


For The Love Of God, Don't Use Holy Nova


It's A Trap!


But if you do, make sure you jump around while spamming it.


Wisdom Of The Ancients


Let me close with something my mother once told me, many years ago: Never, ever forget your big cooldowns. (Sure, it may seem like obvious advice now, but think of how ahead of its time it was in the 1980s.)

Pick the bleakest moment, the moment where everything seems to be about to fall apart (but hasn't yet) and use Divine Hymn. It's one get-of-jail-free card, so use it once every encounter.

Pick any moment where a good number of people are stacked up and most of those people are taking damage and put up a Power Word: Barrier. Then, do it again when it's off cooldown. Try to use it the first time as early as possible (in a situation that makes sense), so you can get it into the encounter as many times as possible (read: up to three times).

Don't hoard cooldowns just in case you need them later. Later never comes to a raid that wipes early. Use them any time things seem at all dicey. It is better by far to err on the side of profligate cooldown usage rather than on the side of miserly cooldown usage. You don't want to wipe with any arrows left in the quiver.

So to sum up:
  • Prayer of Healing, a priest's main AoE heal, should be used in AoE healing situations
  • Greater Heal and Penance are AoE healing tools if you're quick enough
  • Binding Heal heals two people which makes it an AoE heal
  • Holy Nova, which is an AoE heal is, just....no.
  • AoE cooldowns should be used. Even when tank healing
I think we've done some good work here.

Have a great night!

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Discipline Priests Style-Nerfed Again

No, discipline priests weren't nerfed in power. Apparently, Blizzard decided that they were out of balance style-wise, as we've been seeing a steady stream of nerfs to the spell graphics for discipline priests.

It started a month or two ago when Blizzard style-nerfed Penance. Penance, aka the holy machine gun, aka the three shards of golden power, is a channeled heal that fires three blasts of holy power at a target, each one healing the target pretty significantly. It's a very noticeable spell and an iconic discipline priest spell. A further visual effect it had was to cause the target to flinch/jerk slightly upon impact of each golden shard.

Blizzard ended that, apparently permanently. I would explain the terrible ramifications of this, but Sanctùs on the official World of Warcraft forums described it best, with this instant classic:

Penance - 1. An act of self-mortification or devotion performed voluntarily to show sorrow for a sin or other wrongdoing.
2. A sacrament in some Christian churches that includes contrition, confession to a priest, acceptance of punishment, and absolution. Also called reconciliation.

Penanced - To impose penance upon.

What has happened to my Penance? 

I used to provide absolution for my tanks sins as evidenced by the wracking pains he suffered as acknowledment of his iniquities when I penanced him.  Now, my tank just stands there. No wracking pains, no self-mortification.  How is he supposed to receive absolution for his wrong-doings if he no longer has to suffer for them.  I can just see it now, drinking and cavorting with loose blood elfs on the weekends.  Why not he says, penance no longer causes him to suffer for these sins.  Lustful thoughts, no concern, penance is painless.  Coveting his off-tanks ass, no consequences from his spiritual savior.

I worry for the spiritual future of my tank if my I can no longer impose penance upon him with the least degree of suffering.  My tank needs to suffer for his heals, otherwise, he will continue to sin.  Next thing you know he'll be stacking stamina.

Bring back the suffering of my penanced tanks to ensure their salvation in the kingdom of god.



However, today's patch has revealed a new style nerf. Divine Aegis, a shield that procs around a target when the disco priest hits that target with a critical heal, has lost its translucent golden bubble visual. Instead it now looks like a standard Power Word: Shield.


Glowing Disco Ball


That's what Divine Aegis used to look like. This is what Power Word: Shield looks like, and what Divine Aegis now looks like:

Not Pictured: Broken-Hearted Disco Priest


I like the Power Word: Shield graphic. It looks magical and holy. But I also loved the Divine Aegis graphic, because putting people in bubbles was immensely satisfying. I did that.

I've gone through endless World of Log parses and cannot find justification for this change. Discipline priests were undoubtedly overpowered from a stylistic point of view, but rightly so. We're all about style and if you get healed in addition, great. More importantly, we raised raid morale with our spectacular beauty.

I'm sure Blizzard has its reasons and maybe we'll be seeing some style buffs in the coming months. That said, my soul weeps today. Translucent golden tears.

Update: It appears that this may be merely a bug, not an intended change. That, at least, is what a Blizzard blue on the EU forums suggests:  http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/forum/topic/2313881411#6. Call off the panic...for now!

Monday, June 27, 2011

What Is Pride?

Recently, I was (very indirectly and not in any sense singled out) accused by a guild member of not having enough pride in raiding. We hadn't defeated an encounter prior to (what is expected to be) the next tier of raiding coming into existence tomorrow.

What made her angry was that most people (myself included) didn't choose to devote the entirety of the (anticipated) final raid night of this tier to trying to complete the encounter (we killed off our farm bosses in Blackwing Descent first). She felt that this displayed the weak nature of the raid team, a "wimping out" (my words, though I don't think it's a distortion of her feelings), if you will.

I cannot speak for anyone else on the raid team, I only know my own motivations and it led me to wonder: what is the role of pride in raiding? In what ways should one display pride?


Pride In Effort


This post will in no way be a response to that guild member. She's perfectly entitled to feel as she does and I'm not interested in changing her mind. I only mentioned the context in order to explain why I was provoked to think about this issue. I'm not going to spend any time "justifying" the event that annoyed her (because, like many things, it's only right or wrong depending on your approach) but I will mention her occasionally simply to note the differences in our outlooks that may have led to the difference in reaction (which I think is something everyone should bear in mind when evaluating others).

I can confidently say that I do feel a sense of pride in raiding. I think that any time one engages a lot in an activity that involves a skill, one tends to discover a desire to do it as well as possible. Pride, then, comes from the degree one meets that desire. I am certainly not exempt from this when it comes to raiding in the game.

When I raid, I want a few things from myself. I want to be geared well, gemmed and enchanted intelligently (no pun intended as a caster) and possessed of a talent spec that I carefully considered (both based on research and my own experiences playing the class). That's the first and most basic standard: proper preparedness. Secondly, I want to focus as deeply on the task of each encounter as possible. Finally, I want to learn (both encounter mechanics and my own role) swiftly and whenever possible.

Those are where my points of pride come from. I do believe in perseverance. I'm actually quite willing to beat my head against an encounter for days or even weeks. But this is probably the first place where my angry guild member and I part ways a bit. For me, there is no pride in perseverance. For me, perseverance is always balanced against fun.

Generally, this is not an issue that takes consideration. There have not been any raid encounters I've yet run across that I didn't enjoy. Sure, some were difficult and frustrating at first, but even that was fun in a way: trying to unlock the secret. Al'Akir was frustrating at first, because it felt far too random. I actually came to enjoy that encounter, though, as I discovered ways to ameliorate the randomness. That learning process is extremely enjoyable for me.

So, if a boss is blocking progression, I'm happy to fight him for the next ten weeks (though I'd be a little concerned if we, as a group, were taking that long to defeat an encounter). If the boss in question is not blocking progression, and the raid wants to switch to a different boss, I am fine with that, too.


Pride In Being Relevant


A further point of pride that I experience, which is unrelated to my personal performance, is feeling that what I'm doing is "relevant." That quite simply means that I'm working on, at least, the highest current tier of raiding. I don't have to be on the bleeding edge of progression, but I certainly don't want to be working on the tier behind the one that most raiders are on.

I don't, however, have much of a sense of pride in getting a certain achievement or title while it's relevant, "just to say I did." In fact, achievements are relatively unimportant to me in general. I raid for the social aspect of working as a team and the excitement of defeating a difficult boss for the first time. I don't care if I can say that I got the "Light of Dawn" title before patch 4.0.1 dropped (which is good, because I can not say that). This I know is another point of departure between myself and the guild member who felt I (we) lacked pride. I know she feels fiercely passionate about "being able to say" that she did certain things when said things were considered relevant. That's fine, it's simply not where I derive my pleasure or pride.


So Wherein Lies Pride?


I'm a healer. I'd like to heal well. I'm a raider. I'd like to raid on tier. I'm a guild member. I'd like to be considered an obliging, considerate team member.

So my points of pride essentially revolve around those fairly straightforward statements. I don't really consider my place in the greater World of Warcraft universe (world- or server-progression). I have my own views on what healing well entails, but I rarely compare myself to even my fellow healers. Foremost, I'm raiding because it's a game I greatly enjoy playing with others. Pride may goeth before a fall but it sure doesn't goeth before fun, as far as I'm concerned.

I feel badly that my guild member is unhappy about not accomplishing her (guild) goals for this tier. I understand why it upsets her. While I cannot speak for anyone else in the guild, I can say that her goals (in a general sense) diverge from mine subtly but crucially, which leads us to very different concepts of where pride comes into the game and, therefore, what issues are a matter of pride and what issues aren't.

Sunday, June 26, 2011

(Will I Still WoW) When I'm Sixty Four?

I was recently pondering* which was of bigger importance in my life: World of Warcraft or music? The way I decided to evaluate it was, which would I eliminate from my life forevermore, if I had to?

*I was pondering it because I decided to start a music blog, since I enjoy blogging and music is my other great enjoyment. The blog is located at http://havethestoneskilled.wordpress.com/. That is, of course, a shameless plug but only click the link if you're interested in music and my thoughts on said music. I'm not trying to generate stray clicks.

The answer, pretty easily, was World of Warcraft. Part of that, however, was that I expect music to be important to me all my life whereas it's kind of hard to imagine still playing World of Warcraft when I'm 80 years old (rather an understatement). In fact, will World of Warcraft even exist in ten years, when I turn 80?


So Let's Change The Question


Instead of comparing World of Warcraft (which is a single game and will assuredly not last for many years) to music, how about MMOs in general to music? To this point in my life, it's one and the same, as I am not an "MMO player," I am a "WoW Player." I'm really not much of a gamer...you could almost draw a straight line from my Nintendo-playing days as a kid to Prince of Persia in the 1990s to World of Warcraft in terms of my commercial games-playing history. It's sparse.

That said, World of Warcraft has definitely captured me. It's a very big part of my life now, and I can certainly imagine moving to another MMO whenever WoW reaches the end of its run of relevance, which is inevitable (even Blizzard is preparing for a post-WoW reality by developing its new MMO, codenamed Titan).

So the real question is, what about WoW is it that has enthralled me so thoroughly and, therefore, what would need to exist in the future to make it likely that I'll remain addicted to playing MMOs in the way that I am (seemingly) irrevocably hooked to music?


The MMO Magic


There are three main components that attract me to playing World of Warcraft and at least two of them don't seem even remotely close to optimized in my view.

  • Character As Self Expression : Any time you create an avatar, whether it's an icon and profile on a discussion forum or a virtual person in a game, you are representing something of yourself in it (unless you are filling out all the fields purely randomly). It stands to reason that you can therefore use the character in a game as a form of self expression. The more you can customize it to your tastes, the more of your creative being is being expressed.
  • Social Connections : Obviously, a major part of an MMO is the "massively multi-player" portion of the acronym. It's a world not just in terms of virtual geography but in terms of society. There are a whole lot of people to potentially meet, in addition to any friends you knew prior to the game that you now have a new way to relate to. Playing with other people, socializing with other people is a big part of the power of these games.
  • Challenging, Skill-Based Combat : This can be achieved in various ways but the way that World of Warcraft achieves it is through either Player versus Player games or Player versus Dragon encounters (that's right, PVD...that's what playing a fantasy game does, and should, boil down to!). I'm not much for PVP, but I just adore PVD (okay, okay, PVE).

Blizzard does a pretty damn solid job of the third one, in my opinion. It's not inconceivable that it could be better, but there are no glaring flaws with the end-game, in my opinion.

The second aspect is kindof there by default. I don't think Blizzard does a whole lot to maximize the social aspect of the game...which is fine. Blizzard has limited resources in terms of spending time to expand the game and there are a wealth of other ways people can connect on the Internet. Blizzard correctly prioritizes the game aspect to work on.

The first one is a trainwreck for a game of World of Warcraft's magnitude, in my view. You are supposed to feel attached to your character(s) and desire to progress with them, but the opportunities to set them apart from cookie-cutter archetypes are few and far between. The character creation process is surprisingly limited, there's virtually no ability to choose how you want to look from a fashion standpoint and all melee essentially have the same animations as do all casters. Essentially, your only in-game ability to look different is to choose from the tiny selection of hair styles not offered at the character creation screen and tabards. That's about it.

But I didn't write this post to vent about WoW. I came to praise it, didn't I? This is the game that, taken as a package, I love. Isolating what makes the game fascinating to me helps me identify what a future game would need to have to potentially draw me in after WoW.


So Might Future Games Be Even More Addictive?


As computing power and connectedness increases, one can certainly imagine each of those aspects being expanded, honed and made more powerful. Leaving aside end-game content (as what makes fighting dragons fun is awfully subjective and the subject of game design, which I don't feel like getting into here), I think it's clear that the social and self-expression aspects can be increased substantially.

An MMO could allow players to hook their IM clients into the game, whereby whispers, chats, etc, go to an IM client window/tab...even if you are not currently in the game (if you so choose). If you meet someone and don't yet feel like exchanging e-mails or even more personal information, you could still socialize in and out of the game. You could follow guild chat discussions even when you don't have the time/inclination to run the game. It's a fairly simple idea and much more elaborate social immersion could be fashioned, but I'm not trying to paint a "Turn the galaxy into one big computer!" vision of the future...just a simple step forward meant to illustrate that there's more power here to be tapped.

At a very basic level, customization of a character can involve more than WoW allows. Body type selections when creating the character (does my elvish rogue really have to be body builder? Seriously, Blizzard). Clothing slots that allow you to wear a set of gear for looks without losing the benefits of the set of gear you need for dragon-slaying stats. And then of course there are the futuristic possibilities, like having a facial creation tool, allowing you to truly fashion a look that no one else will have. This is supposed to be the virtual you...you probably want to be more "you" (by which I mean, your tastes, not necessarily your real life looks) than one of the thousand human clones running around and disco dancing.


Still Music, Though


Even if I make the assumption that I will be playing MMOs and healing til the day I die in real life, it doesn't change my answer. Music is a bigger part of my life today than World of Warcraft is. I don't play much WoW every day...the two raid nights are where WoW really becomes a big deal. Music is important every day.

A future MMO would have to be a lot more compelling, pulling at my daily entertainment hours more strongly to compete with music. That said, MMOs do have quite a lot of potential to grow. I think World of Warcraft did a lot of things right and therefore rightfully jumped to a position of dominance. Now it remains to be seen whether this form of game stagnates and withers on the vine or is evolved further in next-gen iterations and makes the jump to overall life obsession.

Now if only I could marry the two and listen to music while I raid rather than to all those annoying guildies on Vent who want me to heal or something.